1970 Plymouth Superbird – Average price $233,000
The second most expensive car on this list is a Plymouth. Think about that for a second before realizing that this is the Superbird, a rare car that shares much with the Charger listed previously. In fact, the Superbird is essentially a Plymouth-badged Charger Daytona, complete with aerodynamic nose and humongous rear wing. Either one – the Dodge or the Plymouth – is a good bet.